Somebody's gotta tell me why Jacob is in the top 10 when a couple of other men were passed over. He is big and he has power in his voice, but singing loud and off key does not give you a pass to get through. That big boy couldn't carry a note in tune if he had a bucket brigade. You have to listen to the music in the back and then listen to how far (or little) off key he is. He just isn't that good...he just powers his way through.

I'm glad to see our local boy from Garner NC , Scott McCreery in top 10 ! He should be winner this year joining Carrie Underwood as only Idol Winners whom made it to the big time . Kellie Pickler should have been a Winner during her Idol .

I'm glad to see our local boy from Garner NC , Scott McCreery in top 10 ! He should be winner this year joining Carrie Underwood as only Idol Winners whom made it to the big time . Kellie Pickler should have been a Winner during her Idol .

I havent been watching much this year but seems like a better bunch than last year.

The final 10 have been selected. Let the games begin. I would have had about 2 different choices, but other than Jacob, I can live with the ones that were picked.

The final 10 have been selected. Let the games begin. I would have had about 2 different choices, but other than Jacob, I can live with the ones that were picked.

There are 13 now. I agree about Jacob and would have picked the blond gal over Niama at the end.

Niama SUCKS!!!

I don't know why Steven has such a hard on for her.

The dude they said was "ready for radio" on Tuesday they did not save. How crappy was that?:smack:

would have picked the blond gal over Niama at the end.

Me too, I missed the guys the other night, but boy the girls were all pretty good, much better group (talented) compared to some other years. My favorite Pia :hot:

I'm glad to see our local boy from Garner NC , Scott McCreery in top 10 ! He should be winner this year joining Carrie Underwood as only Idol Winners whom made it to the big time . Kellie Pickler should have been a Winner during her Idol .

I agree with Scott taking it all the way.
I would rather see him take second place though. First place winner does not only have to commit to the tour, but Is also held to a year contract with Idol for recording the first CD.
I think He could do much better if he was able to go out and work on his own.
Either way, he will be the next big name in country.

Niama sucks.
Black dude sucks (not a racial thing, I just don't know his name and he's the only A-A male contestant on the show, so you know who I am talking about).
Dude with all the facial hair (did Teen Spirit last week) SUCKS!
Dude with the feaux-hawk sucks.

and yet, teen spirit guy was saved.
I hope they send his ass home again next week.. him and Niama, I really thought that siezure she had on stage the night before would have done her in. all she was missing was a dead plucked chicken to swing around her head.

and yet, teen spirit guy was saved.
I hope they send his ass home again next week.. him and Niama.

:yeahthat:

Send both of them packing!!!

I love me some Pia :love:

I love me some Pia :love:

OH, I do too.....I really like Scotty too....I don't think he will go all the way but there are people in Nashville just waiting to jump on him....He is going a long way in country music....I can't stand Jacob or Niama (SP).....I think the judges wasted their save last week too....James is cool...Lauren is cute and has good and bad days...Thia & Stephon (SP) will be going very soon....Did I mention I really really like Pia?

Its best Scotty comes n Second. That way he wont have to sign the AI contract and go straight into Country Music.. Go Scotty!!!

OH, I do too.....I really like Scotty too....I don't think he will go all the way but there are people in Nashville just waiting to jump on him....He is going a long way in country music....I can't stand Jacob or Niama (SP).....I think the judges wasted their save last week too....James is cool...Lauren is cute and has good and bad days...Thia & Stephon (SP) will be going very soon....Did I mention I really really like Pia?

Its best Scotty comes n Second. That way he wont have to sign the AI contract and go straight into Country Music.. Go Scotty!!!

I always did say 2nd was the spot to get....We haven't heard the last from Scotty....

Scotty sounds like Randy Travis. :yay: But the poor guy looks like a cross between Clay Aiken and the Mad TV guy.

Scotty sounds like Randy Travis. :yay: But the poor guy looks like a cross between Clay Aiken and the Mad TV guy.

I think he sounds more like Josh Turner....He does look like a cross though....:faint:

I think he sounds more like Josh Turner....He does look like a cross though....:faint:

I didn't even think about Josh Turner. :yay:

OH, I do too.....I really like Scotty too....I don't think he will go all the way but there are people in Nashville just waiting to jump on him....He is going a long way in country music....I can't stand Jacob or Niama (SP).....I think the judges wasted their save last week too....James is cool...Lauren is cute and has good and bad days...Thia & Stephon (SP) will be going very soon....Did I mention I really really like Pia?


It sucks that she's gone. IMO she was the best on the show and no way she should of been eliminated prior to the final 3. What a shame.

It sucks that she's gone. IMO she was the best on the show and no way she should of been eliminated prior to the final 3. What a shame.

I think most people felt she would make it through to the final 3. Maybe that's why voters weren't calling in for her. It is too bad, she has a beautiful voice.

I was totally shocked that my Pia went home last night, She has a awesome great voice, great looks :drool:. I sure hope some music producer contacts her and wants to sign her up.
Not many girls left and I dont think Haley has it to be in the top 3 and Lauren who I like also, and maybe because of her age I dont see her in the top 3, maybe top 5. If one of the remaining girls doesnt win, Im pulling for Scotty.
I just dont understand how someone like Stefano, can still be in it and Pia's gone.

:buddies:I was totally shocked that my Pia went home last night, She has a awesome great voice, great looks :drool:. I sure hope some music producer contacts her and wants to sign her up.
Not many girls left and I dont think Haley has it to be in the top 3 and Lauren who I like also, and maybe because of her age I dont see her in the top 3, maybe top 5. If one of the remaining girls doesnt win, Im pulling for Scotty.
I just dont understand how someone like Stefano, can still be in it and Pia's gone.

I liked Pia a lot myself but my officemate had a good point this morning, she's a great singer but not a great entertainer.

yeah, I was shocked too....I really thought she was going all the way....I bet she has already been contacted and she is probably being begged to sign...My $.02...

This show has been :fixed: for a long...long time.

It's a night time soap opera.

This show has been :fixed: for a long...long time.

It's a night time soap opera.

I have been thinking the same thing for a long time....How in the hell do we know if 30 million people voted last night or not....Oh, that's right, Ryan said so....Pia was clearly the best, so lets get rid of her and get some press....:whistle:

Just remember that you can probably name more runner ups that have gone on to success than winners.

Just remember that you can probably name more runner ups that have gone on to success than winners.

Oh yeah, I am sure this girl isn't going to have any trouble....She has the talent and she sure has the look...

Oh yeah, I am sure this girl isn't going to have any trouble....She has the talent and she sure has the look...

Taylor WHO? Chris WHO? Ruben WHO? Jordin WHO?

The other kids have to wait week by week until the end. Pia can sign a contract immediately and start making big money. The winner has to wait out the first year and do exactly as they are told and the Idol producers have complete control over their recording and artistic life.

I'm glad to see our local boy from Garner NC , Scott McCreery in top 10 ! He should be winner this year joining Carrie Underwood as only Idol Winners whom made it to the big time . Kellie Pickler should have been a Winner during her Idol .

:dingding: :dingding: :dingding: