I bought a whole case of steaks from them this year. It may be a tad pricier than the steaks at the grocery stores, but all I have to do is open my freazer and there it is. The two stores I shop at in Mechanicsville don't really offer a good alternative. McKays, the quality of the steaks there are pretty bad. Food Lion, surprisingly, has nice steaks, WHEN they happen to have steaks (they don't carry much of a selection). So, this was a better alternative for me.
As far as returning a purchase after you bought it....what does their return policy state? Unless they say something about 100% moneyback guarantee, I wouldn't expect them to take it back. While it's unfortunate that you got screwed on the price per pound, it certainly isn't their fault.