I personally suspect that this issue has less to do with equality than some super-small minority wanting to make a political statement and validate their personal beliefs. Anecdotally, given the photos and videos I have seen of individuals who identify themselves as transgender, I don't see how they could meet the physical requirements.
Face it, life is by nature discriminatory. The people who are smartest, hardest working, best looking, most physically fit, etc. typically rise to the top of their respective challenges in life. Everyone is discriminated against in some manner every day of their lives. Whether the person you ask out for a first date accepts or rejects you, whether you get a job or not; whether you are accepted for a car loan or mortgage...
If the military's purpose is to be a lean mean killing machine, then it serves no universal justice to allow unqualified people into the ranks, just because they feel discriminated against, especially if it means putting someone else's life at risk.
When I was a youngster, the popular TV show MASH made light of one guy dressing up as a woman to get out of military service. Now the guys who dress up as women are fighting to be in the military. I guess in military parlance, we would call this an About Face.
---
Face it, life is by nature discriminatory. The people who are smartest, hardest working, best looking, most physically fit, etc. typically rise to the top of their respective challenges in life. Everyone is discriminated against in some manner every day of their lives. Whether the person you ask out for a first date accepts or rejects you, whether you get a job or not; whether you are accepted for a car loan or mortgage...
If the military's purpose is to be a lean mean killing machine, then it serves no universal justice to allow unqualified people into the ranks, just because they feel discriminated against, especially if it means putting someone else's life at risk.
When I was a youngster, the popular TV show MASH made light of one guy dressing up as a woman to get out of military service. Now the guys who dress up as women are fighting to be in the military. I guess in military parlance, we would call this an About Face.
---
| [h=1]General Officers Question Army Chief of Staff's Statement on Transgender Service[/h][h=2]New York Times Quote by General Milley Called a “Refusal to Follow the Science”[/h]SAN FRANCISCO, CA – Two retired General Officers have sent a letter to Army Chief of Staff Mark Milley in response to his concerns about transgender military service. Despite extensive study by a Pentagon Working Group, the RAND Corporation, and an independent commission of retired General Officers and leading scholars and experts, General Milley suggested recently that before the military can lift its ban on transgender personnel, "serious significant issues need to be completely vetted and studied." Generals Claudia Kennedy and Gale Pollock observe in today's letter, however, that "the problem is not a lack of inquiry or a failure to identify simple, straightforward solutions," but rather, that "some military leaders don’t like what the science has already told us," and they "refus[e] to assess transgender personnel by the same standards that apply to everyone else." According to Palm Center Director Aaron Belkin, "When the Marine Corps conducted a faulty study about women in combat, Navy Secretary Ray Mabus stated that arguments based on distorted research were not an option." Belkin added that, "Given the exhaustive research that the military as well as independent experts have already completed on transgender service, General Milley’s call for additional study is just as misleading." Generals Kennedy and Pollock state in today's letter that if there are new, honest and evidence-based objections to transgender military service, then those concerns should be identified so that they can be assessed and resolved. "But to insist that the issue must be studied and vetted when that has already been done (many times)," they conclude, "is to compromise core values that have served as the bedrock of military culture throughout our nation’s history." [h=2]Click here to download a PDF of the letter to General Milley[/h] |
| # # # About The Palm Center The Palm Center is an independent research institute committed to sponsoring state-of-the-art scholarship to enhance the quality of public dialogue about critical and controversial public policy issues. Our research on sexual minorities in the military has been published in leading social scientific journals. The Palm Center seeks to be a resource for university-affiliated as well as independent scholars, students, journalists, opinion leaders, and members of the public. For more information, see www.palmcenter.org |
