Breathtaking is the word that we would use for the accusation by a United States District Judge that Special Prosecutor Robert Mueller is using the criminal case against Paul Manafort to pressure him into turning state’s evidence against President Trump. “The vernacular is to sing,” said the judge, Thos. Ellis III, a veteran of more than thirty years on the federal bench.
It’s not that it’s all that unusual in the course of a case for a judge to make prosecutors show their bona fides. “I think Judge Ellis may just be putting the government through its paces,” Reuters was told by a professor who thinks it unlikely the judge will dismiss the charges Mr. Mueller has handed up against Mr. Manafort. The professor suggests that such lectures are fairly common.
The judge, though, certainly spoke sternly. “You don’t really care about Mr. Manafort. You really care about what information Mr. Manafort can give you to lead to Mr. Trump,” the judge told the prosecutors, adding: “It’s unlikely you’re going to persuade me the special counsel has unfettered power to do whatever he wants.” He pressed a dispute about Mr. Mueller’s mandate.
That involves the question of how far the special prosecutor’s authority extends. One government lawyer balked at providing the judge with more than a redacted copy of a memo supposedly granting Mr. Mueller power to investigate Mr. Manafort’s dealings in Ukraine. When a government lawyer told the judge that the redactions did not pertain to the Manafort case, Judge Ellis snapped: “I’ll be the judge.”
Here Comes the Judge
It’s not that it’s all that unusual in the course of a case for a judge to make prosecutors show their bona fides. “I think Judge Ellis may just be putting the government through its paces,” Reuters was told by a professor who thinks it unlikely the judge will dismiss the charges Mr. Mueller has handed up against Mr. Manafort. The professor suggests that such lectures are fairly common.
The judge, though, certainly spoke sternly. “You don’t really care about Mr. Manafort. You really care about what information Mr. Manafort can give you to lead to Mr. Trump,” the judge told the prosecutors, adding: “It’s unlikely you’re going to persuade me the special counsel has unfettered power to do whatever he wants.” He pressed a dispute about Mr. Mueller’s mandate.
That involves the question of how far the special prosecutor’s authority extends. One government lawyer balked at providing the judge with more than a redacted copy of a memo supposedly granting Mr. Mueller power to investigate Mr. Manafort’s dealings in Ukraine. When a government lawyer told the judge that the redactions did not pertain to the Manafort case, Judge Ellis snapped: “I’ll be the judge.”
Here Comes the Judge