Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 14

Thread: Where wind power rules...

  1. #1

    Where wind power rules...

    Percentage of UK electrical power provided by wind is remarkable.

    https://www.offshorewind.biz/2018/11...1-07&uid=69352
    "I've got to start eating at home more" - J. Dahmer

  2. #2
    Quote Originally Posted by Gilligan View Post
    Percentage of UK electrical power provided by wind is remarkable.

    https://www.offshorewind.biz/2018/11...1-07&uid=69352
    I would not have though even an island nation could generate tens of GW from off-shore wind. I admit to being wrong in my assumption, and impressed.

    Now, that 20 GW "capacity" - how often is it actually achieved, I wonder.
    Last edited by This_person; 11-19-2018 at 08:39 AM.
    Quote Originally Posted by Sapidus View Post
    I'm sure Trump will be charged with more crimes before Hillary.

    Please pin this for future reference

    Pinned, as requested.....

  3. #3
    Quote Originally Posted by This_person View Post
    Now, that 20 GW "capacity" - how often is it actually achieved, I wonder.
    Average capacity factor varies between 30 and 40% on a seasonal basis. So 100% is rare and, sometimes, even newsworthy. I recall when one large grid - I think it was a German one - exceeded 110% for a period.

    The natural variations in wind speed are smoothed out a great deal by the sheer magnitude of the wind power grid and how widely dispersed it is. The days where "the wind ain't blowing" caused major disruption are largely a thing of the past for places like the UK and Germany, and both have dramatically reduced the capacity of standby power generation facilities...something that is controlled by government oversight and legislation.

    The offshore wind industry just getting off the ground in the US won't have too much effect on overall power distribution. Even when fully developed, it will represent a tiny fraction of overall power consumed.

    A key enabling technology for wind and solar is storage...and that is where a lot of R&D is being focused right now, with some pretty darned large storage banks - glorified batteries - already delivered in some places.

    The Us is lagging way, way behind in all of this but that's a blessing...we get to reap the benefits of mature technology without the cost of developing it.
    "I've got to start eating at home more" - J. Dahmer

  4. #4
    Quote Originally Posted by Gilligan View Post
    Average capacity factor varies between 30 and 40% on a seasonal basis. So 100% is rare and, sometimes, even newsworthy.
    This is my point. It's great to say you've got 20MW "capability", but it's mostly theoretical and not actual.

    A key enabling technology for wind and solar is storage...and that is where a lot of R&D is being focused right now, with some pretty darned large storage banks - glorified batteries - already delivered in some places.

    The Us is lagging way, way behind in all of this but that's a blessing...we get to reap the benefits of mature technology without the cost of developing it.
    The Australians have some GREAT batteries they're using for their submarines. Perhaps we could purchase That technology.

    I fully agree that the problem is storage, because storage capacity should handle the lags when "the wind ain't blowing". Off-shore should have few and far between when the wind ain't blowing, but it of course happens.

    This is why I call these great back-up generators - the batteries that can handle the few and far between times when you really need to support the "real" generation capability. I think these are great things to put on one's house - especially a farmer or someone long separated from a stable supply of electricity. You can do a lot, and use the heat generated by the batteries charging to help warm your home, not to mention probably power a great deal of your home a great deal of the time (maybe most of the time). Especially if you combine wind and power.

    But, as a supply from a utility company to keep the factories running and office buildings cool and connected, it just ain't gonna work. I am absolutely for Congress funding, IAW Article One, Section Eight of the Constitution, the "useful arts" (universities, R&D facilities) to help learn the science to make this become a useful power supply for large scale. But, today, it is just simply not capable of doing that.
    Quote Originally Posted by Sapidus View Post
    I'm sure Trump will be charged with more crimes before Hillary.

    Please pin this for future reference

    Pinned, as requested.....

  5. #5
    Quote Originally Posted by This_person View Post
    This is my point. It's great to say you've got 20MW "capability", but it's mostly theoretical and not actual.
    The point is...that they are achieving the kinds of numbers they are, as a percentage of total power, fully taking the capacity factors in to account. Same thing thing in Denmark, Netherlands, Germany, etc. Our current new "hot" development area is Taiwan.

    But, as a supply from a utility company to keep the factories running and office buildings cool and connected, it just ain't gonna work.
    Except that, over there, they are making it work. Except for that. ;-)
    "I've got to start eating at home more" - J. Dahmer

  6. #6
    Power with Control glhs837's Avatar
    Member Since
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    22,539
    They should talk to Tesla........ they seem to have this grid leveling function stuff sorted properly......

    https://electrek.co/2018/05/11/tesla...-service-cost/



    https://www.theguardian.com/technolo...cost-in-a-year
    "I am capable of much unpleasantness."

  7. #7
    Quote Originally Posted by Gilligan View Post
    The point is...that they are achieving the kinds of numbers they are, as a percentage of total power, fully taking the capacity factors in to account. Same thing thing in Denmark, Netherlands, Germany, etc. Our current new "hot" development area is Taiwan.



    Except that, over there, they are making it work. Except for that. ;-)
    The total power required for those countries isn't enough to power two of our major cities. The small wattage required to be a significant percentage there might handle North Dakota here. Maybe. But, last I checked, North Dakota has no "off-shore" areas to make it feasible to get 40% capacity out of a 20MW windmill and have that be a reasonable source of energy. Even in a farm of 20 MW windmills. It would take pretty much all of the land in the state to generate the electricity required for the state.

    I'll bet if we tried in for just Rhode Island, it would be a meaningful percentage of what they need from their off-shore capabilities. But, nobody wants it off their shore, so.....
    Quote Originally Posted by Sapidus View Post
    I'm sure Trump will be charged with more crimes before Hillary.

    Please pin this for future reference

    Pinned, as requested.....

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by This_person View Post

    I'll bet if we tried in for just Rhode Island, it would be a meaningful percentage of what they need from their off-shore capabilities. But, nobody wants it off their shore, so.....
    . Actually..huge offshore farms are going to be built off Rhode Island..and NY..and Mass...and NJ..and CT....
    "I've got to start eating at home more" - J. Dahmer

  9. #9
    Quote Originally Posted by Gilligan View Post
    . Actually..huge offshore farms are going to be built off Rhode Island..and NY..and Mass...and NJ..and CT....
    I remember when they tried to do it off Mass, and the Kennedys said NIMBY.

    It will, of course, eventually happen. It will, of course, supply energy. It will, due to science, not help enough to make an appreciable difference.

    The smallest nuclear power generating station in the United States (Ginna) makes 582 MW. It is essentially not fiscally viable, being so small.

    To make the same energy using 20 MW windmills, working at an optimistic 50% average capacity, you would need 58 in the farm.

    According to the National Renewable Energy Lab, you need about 65-70 acres per megawatt generated total space. At 65 acres/MW X 582 MW X 2 (to take into account a 50% ((very optimistic)) average capacity factor), a total area of 75,660 acres is necessary.

    All of my figures are scaled to be best for the use of the windmills. Using actual numbers would be far worse.

    So, that's 118 square miles of land, or sea, devoted to the same thing that is handled by the smallest American nuclear power plant.

    So, yeah, they're out there, and they make electricity (even in the GW range, totaled, I'm very impressed). They're unreliable, eye-sores, and produce very little energy for the space they take up; but, yeah, I'm sure they'll put them in to make people feel good. Again, I think they're great for very small, remote areas! I'd rather see them for that kind of use for sure!
    Quote Originally Posted by Sapidus View Post
    I'm sure Trump will be charged with more crimes before Hillary.

    Please pin this for future reference

    Pinned, as requested.....

  10. #10
    The "modern" farms are huge..and sited almost always out of view of the shore. 60-80 turbines each is sort of typical of the farms we service over in the North sea, for example. The total number of trubines installed offshore throughout Europe and Scandinavia is in excess of 5000 now and that number continues to climb.

    Once all the projects currently getting underway along the Atlantic seaboard are completed, there will be thousands of turbines in service offshore. The first construction of the large farms is scheduled to begin in 2020, off of New York, with a project off Mass. hot on their heels. Many other states, including MD, are a year or two farther behind..
    "I've got to start eating at home more" - J. Dahmer

Members who have read this thread: 28

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Search:     Advanced Search
Search HELP

| Home | Help | Contact Us | About somd.com | Privacy | Advertising | Sponsors | Newsletter |

| What's New | What's Cool | Top Rated | Add A Link | Mod a Link |

| Announcements | Bookstore | Cafe | Calendar | Classifieds | Community |
| Culture | Dating | Dining | Education | Employment | Entertainment |
| Forums | Free E-Mail | Games | Gear! | Government | Guestbook | Health | Marketplace | Mortgage | News |
| Organizations | Photos | Real Estate | Relocation | Sports | Survey | Travel | Wiki | Weather | Worship |