I've only been able to catch it once. I agree that it seemed like his weekend show, also. I think he'll need to move this show forward on the pace and the way they approach topics, because I don't see how they can support that show 5 days a week with the current program style.
But I really like Gutfeld. I used to have to get up every day at 4, so I would get up an hour earlier to watch RedEye until it ended. THAT show was hilarious. The problem with putting Gutfeld in the 11pm slot is, it competes with late night show hosts and - if it's like HIM - not as much NEWSY as it is funny and satirical.
I do like him on The Five because when I am hearing a load of crap from someone - from a clip or from Juan (who seems to do a Cato the Elder thing and bring in ANY irrelevancy when he has no answer) - I can see Greg taking notes, grimacing slightly and I know he's going to say something REALLY concise and brilliant. Except unlike Ben Shapiro - who will reduce you to tears with facts and logic - Greg will use humor, sarcasm and wit to make you realize what's been said is bullchit.