Maryland Crab Soup

NOTSMC

Well-Known Member
What is that to you? I was talking about Labor Day weekends at my grandparents house and mentioned Maryland crab soup and how my grandmother sometimes used to stick a hunk of beef, chicken or ham in it along with leftover steamed crabs. My boyfriend looked at me like I was nuts and couldn't imagine how that would taste with the creaminess of crab soup. So I asked him what he thought Maryland crab soup was and he said crab meat, heavy cream, sherry, etc etc. He's lived in Maryland since he was eight and he's considerably older than that now (as am I).

I grew up all over but; Baltimore was always home plate. Maryland crab soup was a beef broth base with lots of fresh tomatoes, string beans, carrots, occasionally lima beans, onions, potatoes, lots of steam crabs and the occasional beef, chicken, or ham. It cooked in the big crab pot for hours and smelled exactly like old bay. The soup was good, the leftovers especially; spectacular. Dessert was always something peachy - cobbler, some kind of peach cake, or peach pie, served on forest green depression glass.

So am I wrong - is official Maryland crab soup, cream of or tomato based?
 

Gilligan

#*! boat!
PREMO Member
Our family recipe is tomato based and includes some beef, almost always from well cooked chuck roasts. Some of the crab was just quartered and cleaned, still in the shell; thrown in only for the flavor.
 

vraiblonde

Board Mommy
PREMO Member
Patron
Was it invented by the same maniac who invented Manhattan Clam "Chowder?" ;)

Which is vile and a travesty (like the Manhattan it's named for) but when I was in St. Augustine I had a Minorcan clam chowder, which is similar, and it was outstanding.

There's also a Hatteras clam chowder that is more brothy and light, and it's slurpalicious as well.
 

spr1975wshs

Mostly settled in...
Ad Free Experience
Patron
No comparison. Tomato based crab soup is delicious. Cold beer on the side. Thick cut crusty home made bread, Manhattan clam chowder is an abomination.
Which is vile and a travesty (like the Manhattan it's named for) but when I was in St. Augustine I had a Minorcan clam chowder, which is similar, and it was outstanding.

There's also a Hatteras clam chowder that is more brothy and light, and it's slurpalicious as well.
Tis why I winked. Also, hoped to get other crab soup descriptions.

My Mrs. makes a good variant on new England Clam Chowder, using Scallops instead.
 

NOTSMC

Well-Known Member
Crab soup is tomato based. Cream of crab soup is cream based, of course. I have never had Maryland crab soup with other meat ingredients, but it makes sense to stretch it even more.
That was probably a depression thing with my grandparents and in Baltimore in her day not everyone had a refrigerator as much as they had an icebox. Waste not was the family motto.
 

NOTSMC

Well-Known Member
Tis why I winked. Also, hoped to get other crab soup descriptions.

My Mrs. makes a good variant on new England Clam Chowder, using Scallops instead.
Oh yum. I love scallops. I wish I could find bay scallops vs sea scallops. They're impossible to find. Or dry scallops vs wet scallops.
 

vraiblonde

Board Mommy
PREMO Member
Patron
Tis why I winked. Also, hoped to get other crab soup descriptions.

My Mrs. makes a good variant on new England Clam Chowder, using Scallops instead.

There's a place in Wells ME that makes the VERY BEST seafood chowdah in the universe. It's scallops, shrimp, clams, and lobster in the most heavenly creamy base you could imagine. OMG so good!
 

RoseRed

American Beauty
PREMO Member
Crab soup is tomato based. Cream of crab soup is cream based, of course. I have never had Maryland crab soup with other meat ingredients, but it makes sense to stretch it even more.
This.

Some people order it half and half.
 

phreddyp

Well-Known Member
ah hell no. Two separate flavors that don't belong together. In fact on the sixth day when God created crab I'm pretty certain He said thou shall never mix cream of crab with Maryland crab soup. It's an abomination, sacrilege.
Perhaps one day you will grow up and learn about trying new things, just a thought.
 
Top