kerriellen
Member
This weekend I noticed the new pizza place on 235 (near the new Jiffy Lube) is open. Has anyone been there? If so, how was it? I really want some good NY style pizza.
New Pizza place on 235?
- Thread starter kerriellen
- Start date
kwillia
n/a
yankee44
New Member
Where about?
GWguy
*
Eastern Long Island.
dizzydevilrules
Member
had a steak and cheese with onions from mom and pops sunday for lunch. pretty good but not the biggest sub. the meat is a better quality than steak-um meat. need to get extra cheese next time. the fries were good too, had some sort of coating on them that made them extra crunchy. sorry, no pizza this time. at least they deliver, no one else does.
GWguy
*
I stopped there for lunch today. I didn't want to deal with a whole pizza, so I got some wings. Made fresh while you wait, none sitting under hot lamps. I asked for mild buffalo sauce, and it was exactly that; mild. A little too salty for my taste. No place to sit, take out or deliver only.
aps45819
24/7 Single Dad
What is NY style pizza?
Overpriced?
GWguy
*
Baked in a stone oven until the bottom is dark brown, thin but chewy on the bottom, crispy/chewy on the edge, cheeze not just melted but browning, enough cheeze to extend all teh way to the edge of the pie (and it's called a PIE, not a pizza) and about 2 tablespoons of oil from the good olive oil and pepperoni that drip off when you pick it up to eat it by FOLDING it in half.
NYers, did I leave anything out??
Oh yeah, made with Polly-O products and water from the Hudson river. That's also why NY bagels are so good; it's the water.
Aw man... I wanna go to NY for a pizza.
Last edited:
Dye Tied
Garden Variety Gnome
Hudson River water
I had bagels from Long Island a few weeks back and that thought made me want to 
G
Gemmi
Guest
I agree. I haven't tried the cheesesteak but the pizza is really good. It is better than most around here.
We ordered a pizza from Mom & Pops ( California ) last weekend , maybe its because they just opened and don't have all the kinks worked out but the pizza was awful ... they messed up the pizza we ordered to pick up ... it was missing 2 toppings ... and after ordering a 2nd pizza to be delivered to replace the first one that we had picked up ( yes I made the mistake by not checking the pizza before heading home ) we were really disappointed , its nothing like the Mom & Pops near Mechanicsville ... the wings were smaller too , although the bbq sauce was good . I sure hope they improve , we might try them one more time but its doubtful .
Club'nBabySeals
Where are my pants?
Hubby and I split a Steak & Cheese from there for lunch today. It wasn't bad at all...about on par with Rick's. We'll probably go back.
W
wkndbeacher
Guest
How big are the subs?
