BudoPo
Member
Being a Tom Cruise movie, I wasn't expecting anything great, but it was quite a bit better than I expected. The storyline was pretty good: a seriously romanticized version of the Satsuma Rebellion of 1876, and I thought it got the emotion of the times across pretty well. The cinemetography was pretty good, too. The final battle scene was an obvious copy (or attempt, really) of so many Kurosawa flicks (the director said he uses a lot of influence from Kursawa). It was done well, but not nearly as good as Kurosawa (no big surprise there).
The main problem was with all the talk from the director and producer about how much time and effort they spent on making sure all the details were accurate, in the end the details were unbelievably wrong. Not only the subtle details, like the wrong style of armor, but really obvious ones, like ninja using crossbows (not to mention the tolken ninja attack itself). Some of the things in the final battle didn't make much sense, either.
But, all in all, it wasn't bad, and I'd recommend it if you're into that kind of movie.
The main problem was with all the talk from the director and producer about how much time and effort they spent on making sure all the details were accurate, in the end the details were unbelievably wrong. Not only the subtle details, like the wrong style of armor, but really obvious ones, like ninja using crossbows (not to mention the tolken ninja attack itself). Some of the things in the final battle didn't make much sense, either.
But, all in all, it wasn't bad, and I'd recommend it if you're into that kind of movie.