Straight to jail! NBC News ran an eye-popping headline yesterday: “
Swiss LGBTQ groups praise jail sentence for commentator who called journalist a 'fat lesbian’.” It was personal. The way I talk here on C&C, you better believe when I saw that headline, I immediately whipped out my pocket Constitution and gave that baby a kiss.
Say what you like about body positivity and the virtuousness of eschewing unflattering commentary on others’ physical appearance. Alain Soral did, and before he knew what was happening, on Monday he got sixty days in the slammer for the egregious crimes of “defamation, discrimination and incitement to hatred.”
The target of Alain’s curt, vituperative insult was another Swiss journalist, Catherine Macherel. To be specific, and I hope I don’t offend anyone, I’m just reporting the facts, in addition to calling her a fat lesbian, Alain also uncharitably called Catherine an "unhinged queer activist.” He did it two years ago. In a YouTube interview.
You know me, I had to check and see for myself. There aren’t many pictures of Catherine available online, but I finally found one:
So. I don’t think he should’ve got jail time, but Alain
could have been a little more circumspect. He could’ve just said Catherine was an “obese” lesbian, a “plump” lesbian, or a “lesbian shaped like the Pillsbury Dough Boy.” Or even, “a whole lot of lesbian to love.”
Here in the U.S., thanks to the First Amendment, defamation is not a
crime. Defamation is also not actionable if the insult is
true. But if you do injure somebody with a
false statement — injure them in terms of dollars and cents — you can then sue them in civil court for restitution.
Hurt feelings don’t support a defamation claim. Generally speaking, you can’t get any money for your hurt feelings, and you sure can’t lock people up.
If it could talk, the Constitution might say,
toughen up and insult them back. Remember “sticks and stones” from when you were a kid? Or that old chestnut, “I’m rubber and you’re glue?” There’re lots of ways.
And who knows what the crimes of “incitement to hatred” or “discrimination” might be. It all sounds pretty Orwellian. Thought crimes, and so forth.
Instead, Switzerland’s out-of-control LGBTQ++ crowd has pulled the levers of power in that unfortunate country
so hard such that just insulting a gay person can get you thrown in prison. And that’s right where we’d be in this country, you’d better believe it, absent the First Amendment. Just look at what they’re doing to Trump. He didn’t even call a lesbian “fat.”
Fat lesbian jails journalist; 5th Cir. expands censorship ban; historic Speaker removal; Pritzger disses Kamala; citizen journalist does media's job; gender bender war news; EU disses Ukraine; more.
www.coffeeandcovid.com