to steal from "A Field of Dreams", if you build it, they will come. Check out the Inn at Little Washington - it's in Washington, Va. Not exactly the big city, not even close.
But it's like one of the top 10 restaurants in the region. You would be amazed at where chefs will go, where they choose to live. Getting and retaining a trained wait staff is hard, particularly in this area. But college kids (cough St. Mary's) often are very good. I don't know where Café D'Artists recruits, but they are well trained. Of course you have a hands on owner/chef who is involved in his supply chain as well as his restaurant. I guess it's a problem for some that menus at places like this change with the seasons, with what is available. The chefs would rather change the menu than serve something they feel is substandard.
But people also have to expect to pay a little more and to tip accordingly, not be cheap.