The only auto body shop I trust with my baby is Certified Auto Body in White Plains, I've taken my car to them twice...I just got my car back from them (11/24) after a week of fixing my front end after an accident with a deer. They know what they are doing and the guys are really sweet guys.
I stopped by the shop to check on her after a couple days and they showed me what they were doing to her and how long everything was going to take. They deal with insurance company so I don't have to do any of the paper work, just some address/contact forms before I left. They are awesome and I have NO COMPLAINTS!!