Erie is great unless you have an accident. I had them for years, got married and even though my new spouse had an accident more than 5 years before due to ice on the road they refused to insure him if he drove my car.
I have had GEICO for many years without any complaints. However, I would not use them for my home that is with Liberty Mutual. They sold their homeowners division and the idiot company sent me a letter that ...
1 - I did not have a fire hydrant near my home. (there is one in front of the house next door - less than 50 yards away)
2- I had to trim my trees as they were too close to the house, but they could not tell me how far away they needed to be.