New York officials "have failed to show that the broad discretion afforded to licensing officials" under city code "is consistent with the history and tradition of firearm regulation in this country," U.S. District Judge John Cronan said
in his ruling.
City law lets officials reject applications for gun permits if they determine a person is not "of good moral character" or for any other "good cause."
The ruling came in a case brought by Joseph Srour, a New York City resident who applied for gun licenses from the New York City Police Department (NYPD) in 2018 and 2019.
NYPD officials denied the applications because Mr. Srour had been arrested, fined for traffic violations, and had his driver's license revoked. He was never convicted of a crime.
The arrests, Mr. Srour not disclosing them to the NYPD, and his driving record “reflect negatively upon your moral character and casts grave doubt upon your fitness to possess a firearm," city officials wrote in one of the rejection letters.