Sorry for not posting for a bit. I am under contract on the house! Everything has gone amazingly well so far. Here's the timeline:
Day 1: Posted on Zillow & Craigslist
Day 3: Listed on MLS for $299 with NetRealtyNow
Day 4: Two showings
Day 6: First day of open house, three people came through
Day 7: Second day of open house, 5 people came though
Day 8: Realtor called to ask if house was still available, his client would be making an offer!
Day 12: Received full price offer!
Day 15: Accepted offer. Got a call a few hours later that someone else wanted to put in an offer.
I've passed the home inspection so far. Still need septic inspection and appraisal and then I should be good to go (it's never certain until closing though).
The person who bought the house came to the open house Sunday afternoon.
So i'm plenty pleased with these results of course. The open house was pretty effective I think. I had a number of people come without realtors, though several of those had a realtor they would use if they bought. I had 4 open house signs out, but mostly to direct people as we are a bit off the main road. I didn't feel like I had any nosy neighbors or random snoopers. Most people seemed to actually be house hunting, and a couple were near the end of their lease and needed to buy soon. I honestly do not understand why Realtors kept telling me open houses don't work. Maybe my experience is unusual. As it is though, I would strongly recommend having an open house. I had a couple realtors call to say they would come during the open house, who would have otherwise scheduled to see it another time. That would have meant more separate times cleaning the house, which is absolutely the hardest part of selling a house.
Having sold without a realtor, I am saving $5,069 on my $179,000 sale (179000*3%-299). Most of my time selling was the clean up, with a realtor would not have done anyway. So actual time a Realtor would have spent will be around 20 hours max, which equates to about $250 an hour. That's certainly more than I've ever made before!
Due to the response here and asking friends, I would recommend others list their house on SOMD.com. I was planning to after the open house, but already had an offer. I asked several people where they heard about the house, and everyone said Realtor.com, Homes.com, and Trulia.com. The only interest I had from Craigslist was people asking if I would do rent to own. I don't think I had any interest except from MLS related listings actually, including the couple people who didn't have a realtor.
Another note: one of the most common arguments I hear for using a Realtor is because they understand the contracts. In my experience of attempting to buy a couple houses, buying this house, and now selling it, Realtors don't understand the contracts any more than I do. Every contract I have seen has had multiple errors. They are generally small, and so I let it go (I don't think they could handle me rewriting their contract), but don't let that argument scare you. You can also pay a lawyer a couple hundred bucks to look over a contract. Certainly not worth the thousands a realtor charges.
This is long enough for now, I'll post some more thoughts later, and will keep everyone updated on the process. Closing is early June.