That area in the photo clearly shows the dead spot, one of two like that, and we did realize it came from a spillage of your materials on the lawn that were attempted to be washed into the ditch by the technician using a garden hose at my home. I did not believe it was necessary to go that deep into the cause, but you obviously have no problem sidestepping ownership of a problem caused immediately following your employee's treatment of the lawn. We did initially think it was caused by a liquid maliciously, but when the entire lawn began to show similar signs of browning, but not to this heavy a degree, we looked more closely at the stress throughout the property on the lawn. The neighbor's yard, as far back as the rear of their yard, showed similar problems and is now as completely dead as most of my "professionally installed" lawn. No, they are not dormant. They are dead. That is a clear sign that not only was the lawn poorly done, but also must have been a far too heavy usage of an annual grass seed and insufficient amounts of perennial seed. True lawns do not die under the stress of heat - they go into a dormant dry state until conditions are sufficient to sustain growth. Parts of the yard have survived, but more than 60% died.
You are mistaken if you believe the neighbor's yard did not show similar signs and I encourage you to reach out to him to confirm my information to assure you this is factual. His lawn is now almost entirely clover, which does not exist in other lawns around his home. So where did that clover come from? Again, poor seed quality from MRW. And why did it grow? Poor pre-emergent application by MRW. The weeds in that photo of my yard clearly show heavy weed growth in a brand new lawn. All of the light green and the brown are weeds, which cover most all of the ditch. It is unfortunate you could not catch more of the lawn to better show how heavy the weed growth was so early in the yard's growth (after you killed all grass and weed previously on the lawn).
I am pleased you chose to respond and once again demonstrate a complete unwillingness to both accept any responsibility for unacceptable work, but to also deny any accountability or concern for customer satisfaction. This was my experience with Wayne and other employees at MRW from the very beginning of signs of stress on our yard. This should help others to see both the good and bad of your lawn service.
And in response to the "offer" to give me a cut rate on doing the lawn over (again!), that was simply unreasonable. Nobody else never put a single product on the lawn and I paid MRW as the sole provider for my lawn maintenance (fertilizer, herbicide, etc). But when that caused a problem you simply wanted me to pay you again (after the first $2500 I paid you I got a "generous" offer of taking $1000 off of the price to do it again). So I had a consideration to make. Pay you another $1500 when you already proved you couldn't do the job right the first time...so what would make me trust the second time you could get it right? Pay again for what was never right? I work far too hard for money to throw more and more money at a problem I was not responsible for and did not cause. Your guy did it...own up and be accountable. That's how businesses work and that's why you carry insurance against damages your employees may cause. If employees were perfect you would need no insurance. I do not blame MRW just to blame them. I blame MRW because you failed 2 different customers and your service was terrible and your guarantee of a beautiful lawn meant absolutely nothing. I'm out $2500 and not one more customer deserves to receive from your company the accusatory treatment, just like in your post above, or the poor service I received. They should get what they pay for, nothing more and nothing less.
Guess I need to take this comment by comment and I hope this is the end of it.
1.) This is an extreme burn of the lawn and there would be much evidence of the spill had it occurred. My partner examined your lawn and found no evidence of fertilizer spill in the burned area. If my tech was able to wash it away as you said, there would still be evidence of the spill, and this is not normal procedure anyway. My technicians are taught to own up to their mistakes and a spill of this magnitude would have been well documented. If this was our fault, we would admit it. You don't want to believe my partner.
2.) We do not use annual rye in our seed. Our blend is a blend of turftype tall fescue and Kentucky bluegrass. You are quite mistaken that a new perennial lawn doesn't die because of heat and drought. They certainly will if they are not watered and mown properly and have poor soil conditions. A lawn takes a few years to become fully established. In that time, you have to be willing to care for it with proper water, mowing, fertilizer and reseeding. There are a lot of examples of that especially this year. Aeration and seeding is usually recommended after a tough summer, especially one like we just had. We leave our customers instructions how to care for the lawn.
3.) Once again, you want to blame us for your weed problems, yet I have not been able to treat either yours or you neighbors lawn all summer. Certainly your lawns have gone into stress from the tough summer and the turf can not compete and choke out the weeds. Clover (all varieties) is everywhere and very common. Weed seeds can remain in the soil for a very long time and germinate under the right conditions. I assure you that our seed is a quality blend of only perennial Turf Type Tall fescue and Kentucky bluegrass. I can show you the tag of the seed that we use. I look at the National Turf Evaluation Program and I choose what I think is the best ones from my suppliers. They are always in the top 50 on the UMD recommended list. On occaision we will use John Deere Transition Blend which is still a weed-free blend of their best tall fescue varieties.
4.) Your lawn had some winter annual weeds that came into the lawn after the renovation. This is also typical of a new lawn. However, you have to be patient before you spray a new lawn with a phenoxy type herbicide for broadleaf weeds. The lawn needs to have well established secondary roots and that usually happens in April. Drought hit us quite early this year, and I suspect what you were experiencing was drought stress in the lawn. I know that is hard to believe with all the snow we had, but it is true. We had some calls the 1st of April for brown lawns and it was drought stress. Once people got the message and started watering things were ok
5.) I feel your pain. I know that $2500 is a lot of money to spend for something you do not feel you got your money's worth. What you need to realize is that it is time to stop grasping at straws and blaming us for your failure and accept the fact that the lawn is just going to take time, money, and effort to become established into a good quality perennial lawn. Wayne and Bobby both did their best to work things out with you but you just insisted on blaming us and refused to work with us. Your problem could have been negotiated to a better end for you. The sooner you admit to YOUR failure, the sooner you will be able to get what you want and fix your problem.
We are certainly licensed and bonded. My technicians are not perfect and they make a few mistakes. We do not create an air where they are afraid to admit them. They are encouraged to admit and fix them if they can or ask for help. That is the only way they will learn from them and avoid them in the future. And, as I said earlier, as a company, we will admit and will bend over backwards to fix our mistakes and make it up to the customer if we make them. But, we won't admit to anything that is not our fault.
In closing, I am done on this thread and do not feel I need defend the actions of my partner, my manager, my technicians or my company any further. What I would encourage you to do is to think about what you post before posting, and ensure that it is in fact factual and not the fiction you describe.
Richard L. LaNore
MRW Lawns, Inc.
Technical Director
DW-You know that you have nothing to worry about