POLL: Should teachers be allowed to use force

How do you feel about classroom discipline?

  • Bring spanking back

    Votes: 13 37.1%
  • Grabbing a child who is running and not listening is okay

    Votes: 16 45.7%
  • Time Outs are okay

    Votes: 17 48.6%
  • Do not touch my child ever!

    Votes: 3 8.6%
  • Do nothing and just call the parents

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Any classroom incident merits a call to the parents.

    Votes: 13 37.1%

  • Total voters
    35
  • Poll closed .

drivingdaisy

New Member
As a teacher I wouldn't want to physically discipline another person's child.

It would have been nice to have a button that released some sort of sleeping gas (temporary and completely safe of course). And maybe I could be allowed a nerf gun to pelt them with occasionally (but no guns allowed ahhhhhh... :cds:). But I also want to be able to use these items on the parents of the students.
 

ZARA

Registered User
I also want to be able to use these items on the parents of the students.

Some parents need it way more than the students do.

What breaks my heart is when I see a parent so disheveled, stressed, and angry at a child that wont behave and then I hear, "Will you F*ing shut up!" or other things along the "F'ing" line. I hate hearing parents cuss their children. It's uncalled for and it's wrong.

I have no problem stepping in and asking the parent if there is something I can do to help them. I will do just about anything to calm the parent and distract them from being abusive. And the whole time I am thinking to myself, "Do you have any idea how painful and damaging your words are?!?"
 
Some parents need it way more than the students do.

What breaks my heart is when I see a parent so disheveled, stressed, and angry at a child that wont behave and then I hear, "Will you F*ing shut up!" or other things along the "F'ing" line. I hate hearing parents cuss their children. It's uncalled for and it's wrong.

I have no problem stepping in and asking the parent if there is something I can do to help them. I will do just about anything to calm the parent and distract them from being abusive. And the whole time I am thinking to myself, "Do you have any idea how painful and damaging your words are?!?"

Yeah... horrible. I usually just say, "If you don't knock it off, I am going to spank you in front of all these people.":coffee:

I am much too calm sometimes.
 

BigBlue

New Member
Bring back corporal punishment.

Calling the parents is not always going to solve the issue, I have seen incidents of where the parent was a bigger part of the problem because they refused to discipline their child and thought their child could do no wrong. Give the teachers the ability to control their classrooms and handle their students, we trust them with the ability (and expect them) to judge a child’s learning needs, to keep them safe, to look after their welfare and to help them grow into mature adults, why not let them judge a child’s disciplinary needs, after all, discipline is major tool needed to raising young children into mature adults, why not give teachers that tool.


When I went to school the principal was allowed to spank your arse and the teachers were allowed to smack your hand with a wooden ruler. They also called my parents so when I got home I got my arse beat again. I also remember having to write a thousand times “I will not disrupt the class or disrespect the teacher” because I could not control my mouth. The point, I think I turned out okay and my self esteem and ego didn’t suffer for it, in fact, it made me a better person and looking back I’m glad that those principals, teachers and my parents beat my arse into shape and didn’t let me became a worthless human being.

What I see children of today lacking, discipline, there’s no discipline. Parents are trying to be their child’s BFF’s and don’t want to be the bad guy. Newsflash to those parents, you’re a parent, you are suppose to be the bad guy. Letting your little four year old scream no in your face may seem cute but when they are doing it when they are eight I bet you will no longer going to find it cute, and it’s too late to correct it.

As for my kids, I’ve told their teachers that if they if my kids gave them any troubles, they had my permissions to smack them and then to give me a call and I will take it from there. Both my kids know that Dad doesn’t take any crap and if they want to act like an imbecile, they can do it on the privacy of our own house and nowhere else.

BTW, you trust those “strangers” to keep your child’s life be ensuring the child safe and secure during their time at school but you won’t trust those same “strangers” with knowing when your child needs a little “attitude adjustment”, ironic.: coffee:
This!!! Parents lie and so do kids. Parents never believe teachers ,no matter what .Some how their child is always being the picked on kid and is always a angel at home and would never ,ever , never do anything disruptive at school ! If a teacher wants to grab a kid and throw him out of the room, more power to him or her .
 

BlueBird

Well-Known Member
All votes and comments are appreciated.

91.5% of us who voted think it's okay for a teacher to touch a student if the situation calls for it.

67% of us are okay with the school NOT calling us for every single incident.

Everyone who voted agrees that some form of classroom punishment is necessary.

29 out of 35 voters are okay with a teacher grabbing a child or would be okay if schools brought spanking back.

It's good to see that folks living here still appreciate discipline in our schools.
 
Top