Does anyone remember the beginning years of popular MMA? Back when UFC didn't have weight classes and matched different styles? You would have wrestlers fighting boxers fighting Karate experts.
In the end they found Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu and wrestling came out on top the most, with the random win to a good stand-up knockout. So now we get fighters with a mix of those three. Too much stand-up (boxing) and you get submitted, too much BJJ/wrestling and you may get knocked out before you take it to the ground.
Thank you. That is exactly what this is; a one dimensional fighter, super dominant in that one dimension, getting beat, soundly, by a well rounded MIXED MARTIAL ARTS fighter.
It is testament to the sad state of boxing that so many are leaping on this as a BOXER prevailing and that simply could not be further from the truth. a better MIXED MARTIAL ARTIST beat an inferior mixed martial artists.
Rousey has been physically dominant and able to overwhelm her opponents and that is all well and good. However, not one MMA fan has missed the obvious weakness of RR; she is totally untested in the deep water of going even ONE round let alone several. How would she do if she had to go a round or more? She has also been virtually one dimensional; submission. How would she do against someone who could defend submissions? How would she do against someone who could defend take downs? How would she do against someone who could kick and keep it up, the withering, brutal path of many a fighter to victory in MMA? And, how would she do against someone who was, finally, her physical equal?
Holly Holmes won because, yes, she can strike, box, very well, she can DEFEND take downs, she can defend submissions. Hell, she even took RR down and, on top of it all, she can kick.
She punched RR, she hit her with an elbow, she defended, she took her down, her inside kick was nasty.
She won an MMA bout because she was the better MMA fighter in a proper size and weight match up. She beat an 'unbeatable' champ who had been whipping ass, one dimensional, and HAD NOT BEEN tested. Not because she is a great boxer.
The rematch will be a whole other ball game because RR does have the basic skills. She's just never been tested. She got frustrated, she got tired, she absolutely got punched but just as importantly, kicked and a nasty elbow in the first. And she got desperate and she got her ass kicked.