If this doesn't open the eyes of the Tebowtards nothing will..
Just because Tebow spanked your beloved Bucknuts a few years ago doesn't mean he's a bad QB. You really need to get over your hatred for him.
The guy took a 1-4 team, led by what most people were calling a pretty good QB in Kyle Orton, and took them to 8-8, then a playoff win. That's a 7-4 record. By comparison, Manning has the team at 13-3. Better, sure, but why heap all the praise on Manning if he has a team that merely needed a competant QB? They made other upgrades to help Manning out.
The Denver defense was decent last year, but there were plenty of games they didn't show up. Tebow's passing numbers weren't great, but he made plays when he needed to (4th quarter and OT), he helped the running game, and the bottom line is he won games.
I don't get it. We saw the guy, with all his limitations, pick up Denver and lead them to the playoffs AND a first round win. How in the hell could his stock have fallen so far that he isn't ahead of Sanchez???? That not one team, not the Chiefs, not the Jags, not the Raiders, Mark is, to me, all the accuracy of Tebow (slam) absent the leadership skills and absent the running skills.
The Jets never even gave him a chance. Not even in the last freaking game so he could audition for someone else AND bring them maybe something in trade.
I wonder what it really is? Do they hate him in the film room? In practice? Good lord. Rex Grossman started two years ago. :shrug:
Simple -- he's not a very good QB in a traditional sense. His passing isn't very good and in practice his skills don't translate. When you're practicing in a pass-oriented offense and you're not a pass-oriented QB, you struggle. He needs the type of run-oriented, option-based offense that they used for him in Denver. He doesn't fit the Jets system beyond their wildcat package.
Nonetheless, I think they made a mistake by not trying him out the way Denver did. What did they have to lose? McElroy clearly isn't the solution and Sanchez isn't either. With Tebow, you at least know he led a winning team the previous year.
Sanchez and Tebow based on skill alone isn't even a contest, Sanchez wins easily....
Another point I'd like to make with regards to Denver, as soon as he was traded, there was a fuss by the Broncos locker room about how they couldn't stand him...so again, I don't think he was inspiring anyone...I think it was the product of the schedule and a weak AFC West.
I disagree. Sanchez was the only other QB that couldn't complete 50% of his passes half the time, so I don't see a sizeable passing advantage by Sanchez. On top of that, Tebow is a better leader, crunch-time player, and a far superior runner and play action passer. You can't discount all of that when discussing skill.
As for the locker room crap, you're overblowing that. A couple of guys didn't like the way he led because they're whiny crybabies and then the rest of them didn't like the locker room circus that the was caused by the MEDIA, not Tebow.
But if you want to talk about weak schedule and weak AFC West, Manning has 1 less loss than Tebow on a significantly upgraded Denver team. Why all the praise on him if he's on a team with an easy schedule in a bad division that's better than it was last year?