AI - Taylor or Katherine

[scratch]

Neither I thought the show stunk I think both of them are horrible and after the show is over nobody will remember either one of them!!!!!!! Should have been Paris vs Chris!!!!!!!

 

[dems4me]

Its rigged They gave her a crappy song to sing and Taylor a good song, all this after a year of them having to predominately sing male songs Poor Katt. I hope she wins inspite of the producers

 

[Tina2001aniT]

Its rigged They gave her a crappy song to sing and Taylor a good song, all this after a year of them having to predominately sing male songs Poor Katt. I hope she wins inspite of the producers

She is just not as good, AT ALL......

 

[Jameo]

Its rigged They gave her a crappy song to sing and Taylor a good song, all this after a year of them having to predominately sing male songs Poor Katt. I hope she wins inspite of the producers

They didn't give her crappy songs to sing, She just can't sing
(Actually she did her first 2 songs VERY WELL, her original SUCKED!)



Gooooo Taylor

 

[Tina2001aniT]

They didn't give her crappy songs to sing, She just can't sing
(Actually she did her first 2 songs VERY WELL, her original SUCKED!)



Gooooo Taylor

I have to say though, that I liked the WORDS to her original song, if someone else sang it, and sang it differently, I think I would like it

 

[dems4me]

They didn't give her crappy songs to sing, She just can't sing
(Actually she did her first 2 songs VERY WELL, her original SUCKED!)



Gooooo Taylor

Goooooo Kathering

Even the judge's couldn't figure out and apologized for her singing such a crappy song created by the show..

 

[workin hard]

I hope Taylor wins...I'm not a big fan of Katherine.

 

[nomoney]

I am so proud to say that I have NEVER watched American Idol, nor will I ever watch it in the future.

loser

 

[Jameo]

Goooooo Kathering

Even the judge's couldn't figure out and apologized for her singing such a crappy song created by the show..

She still did a terrible job singing it




GOOOOO TAYLOR!!!!

 

[Geek]

Neither I thought the show stunk I think both of them are horrible and after the show is over nobody will remember either one of them!!!!!!! Should have been Paris vs Chris!!!!!!!

Pipe down

 

[cattitude]

Actually, both of the last songs were lousy. The thing about Taylor, and has been all year, is that he manages to put his signature on what he sings and he feels what he sings. I don't think he has the greatest voice, but he has an entertainment quality about him.

Katherine has an outstanding voice but she is just that...a singer. She doesn't connect with the audience.

It has nothing to do with male songs, Dems, they aren't supposed to "imitate" the artists, they are supposed to sing the songs and make them their own and that's where Katherine has trouble.

 

[Otter]

Chris


I'm not watching AI EVER again

They didn't give her crappy songs to sing, She just can't sing
(Actually she did her first 2 songs VERY WELL, her original SUCKED!)



Gooooo Taylor

:liarliarpantsonfire:

 

[dems4me]

Actually, both of the last songs were lousy. The thing about Taylor, and has been all year, is that he manages to put his signature on what he sings and he feels what he sings. I don't think he has the greatest voice, but he has an entertainment quality about him.

Katherine has an outstanding voice but she is just that...a singer. She doesn't connect with the audience.

It has nothing to do with male songs, Dems, they aren't supposed to "imitate" the artists, they are supposed to sing the songs and make them their own and that's where Katherine has trouble.

but she's soo bad sometimes she really does make them "her own" and it puts her signature on them too :shrug:
Goooo Katherine!!!!

 

[Tina2001aniT]

but she's soo bad sometimes she really does make them "her own" and it puts her signature on them too :shrug:
Goooo Katherine!!!!

\

huh

 

[Jameo]

:liarliarpantsonfire:

But they did show Chris lastnight

 

[workin hard]

But they did show Chris lastnight

I miss him

 

[dems4me]

\

huh

I was trying to be funny, sorry, I won't try THAT again.

 

[Somdmommy]

Last night was all Taylors..That poor girl. The song they gave her was just wrong. I think they both sing very good, but I do like Taylor alot better.

 

[Tina2001aniT]

I was trying to be funny, sorry, I won't try THAT again.

It just didn't make sense to me, joke musta went over my head......carry on....

 

[Dondi]

But they did show Chris lastnight

Yes, they did show Chris last night.....losing.

The only time I saw him was on the "Had a Bad Day" song. They showed that shot of the stunned look on Chris' face when Ryan bluntly told him he was going home.