Originally posted by vraiblonde
I love the FBI and the CIA - mostly when they're arresting and torturing criminals.
Because that's a good way to limit our options, destroy our credability, and get crappy intel in the process. It should be our goal to rise above cathartic barbarism.
About Jose Padilla: The NYT is a liberal nutball paper and their editors should be executed for treason.
Yeah, them free press bastards. Kill 'em all! Especially those ass-kissers at Fox News!
Jose Padilla is guilty as sin and everyone knows it.
Not me! I don't see a conviction. Just a stalled case and a piss-soaked writ of habeas corpus. If he's so guilty, then let's have a public trial. Let's hear the government's case. If not, let the bastard go and keep an eye on him.
Somehow, some nutties have decided that terrorists must actually commit a crime, not just be involved in one or planning one, before you can take them into custody.
Those damn forefathers. Crazy guys! Must have been too stoked up on that whole "freedom" thing to write the thought police into the Constitution. But, never fear, Ashcroft is working on that problem.
I'm totally into terrorism prevention, and if it means holding some dirtbag in a jail cell while the lawyers make a case, so be it.
Hey, me too! Seriously. But that's why we have a bond system. Padilla should be arraigned, assigned council and denied bail, just like any other U.S. CITIZEN. Locking him in a brig under some bogus "enemy combatant" crap just weakens the Bill of Rights and opens doors to lots of scary Nazi precidents that I don't want to consider. As for the rabble locked up in Gitmo and Abu Grahib(?), I consider their fate to be more a matter of international relations rather than U.S. law. Different kettle of fish. But Padilla is a citizen. He could be a deranged, treasonous one, but he deserves due process on his way to the gurney...as do we all.