Fantasy Challenge: Michigan

[nachomama]

I say everyone has to pick one person outside the top 25 in points. If that driver finishes in the top 5, they earn 20.

 

[homedepot20]

My imput for any change is - 10 points for the POLE SITTER and leave all else the same if ANTYHING is Needed for a change of pace ! Actually I am satisfied with how it is now!

 

[Beaver-Cleaver]

I'm interested in hearing all ideas and will see what we can do before Indyawnapolis.

I'm thinking making everyone make one pick outside the top 12... then again, there are a lot of cars capable of being competitive every week who are outside the top 12: Junyer , Reutimann, Kahne, Bowyer, Montoya, Truex, Harvick (#### RCR), McMurray and Sliced Bread.

Of the guys 25th and back, I see maybe 5 drivers who are capable of getting a top 10 here and there. (Allmendinger, Ragan, Sliced Bread, Sorenson, Menard)

Maybe moving the target from top-5 to top-10, and allowing one more pick... what does everyone think of that idea?

 

[Beaver-Cleaver]

My imput for any change is - 10 points for the POLE SITTER and leave all else the same if ANTYHING is Needed for a change of pace ! Actually I am satisfied with how it is now!

Why? Qualifying is rained out half the time. :shrug:

 

[clevalley]

I'm interested in hearing all ideas and will see what we can do before Indyawnapolis.

I'm thinking making everyone make one pick outside the top 12... then again, there are a lot of cars capable of being competitive every week who are outside the top 12: Junyer , Reutimann, Kahne, Bowyer, Montoya, Truex, Harvick (#### RCR), McMurray and Sliced Bread.

Of the guys 25th and back, I see maybe 5 drivers who are capable of getting a top 10 here and there. (Allmendinger, Ragan, Sliced Bread, Sorenson, Menard)

Maybe moving the target from top-5 to top-10, and allowing one more pick... what does everyone think of that idea?

Are you saying pick the top 5, points stay the same - but add a sixth pick which must be out of the top 10 and if they finish anywhere in the top 6 you get x points? (x to be determined?)

 

[huntr1]

I'm interested in hearing all ideas and will see what we can do before Indyawnapolis.

I'm thinking making everyone make one pick outside the top 12... then again, there are a lot of cars capable of being competitive every week who are outside the top 12: Junyer , Reutimann, Kahne, Bowyer, Montoya, Truex, Harvick (#### RCR), McMurray and Sliced Bread.

Of the guys 25th and back, I see maybe 5 drivers who are capable of getting a top 10 here and there. (Allmendinger, Ragan, Sliced Bread, Sorenson, Menard)

Maybe moving the target from top-5 to top-10, and allowing one more pick... what does everyone think of that idea?

You can barely keep up with the challenge the way it is. You will never be able to keep track of the points if you do this clusterfuck of a change. If you insist on making a change to the scoring/points earning process this late in the season, go with Cle's idea.

Why don't we just say "pick 10th place for 20 points?"

 

[homedepot20]

Why? Qualifying is rained out half the time. :shrug:

My only reason is that its still a guessing pic ! Rain or Shine

 

[gumbo]

You have to call the 10th place pick like we do with the winner or your 6th pick is automatically your 10th pick?

I say 20 points max for 10th place and everybody gets to pick. No redistributing my points to those "less fortunate" than me. I worked for my numbers, I earned them fair and square. Or we will have to start calling you Barack OGumbo.

Yes your extra pick would be for 10th..Like I said it's a lot harder than pickin the winner...Jimmy Johnson Jimmy Johnson Jimmy Johnson Jimmy Johnson Jimmy Johnson Jimmy Johnson Jimmy Johnson Jimmy Johnson.