Is there a such thing as a bad dog collar?

ZARA

Registered User
You decide.

horrid collars.jpg
 

Roman

Active Member
That is horrible!! No such thing as a BAD Dog, just bad people that do things like that.
 

Freefaller

Active Member
Just a guess


What a horrible picture and what an awful thing to do to a dog (or any animal). However, I don't believe that what is pictured is actually a dog collar, although apparently some cruel SOB used it as one. I believe what we're looking at are tire chains that you can wrap on your tires in icy conditions.
 

MR47930

Member
I use this exact collar and I assure you that my dogs neck looks nothing like this. Clearly the owner shouldn't have a dog, you would have to pull with an incredible amount of force for the back of the neck to have lacerations.
 

Ken King

A little rusty but not crusty
PREMO Member
What a horrible picture and what an awful thing to do to a dog (or any animal). However, I don't believe that what is pictured is actually a dog collar, although apparently some cruel SOB used it as one. I believe what we're looking at are tire chains that you can wrap on your tires in icy conditions.

Tire chains? :killingme It is a prong/pinch collar, nasty device, those using them need to be subjected to one.
 

Roman

Active Member
Even though my Dogs are chipped, I have collars for their license, and medic alert tags.
 

vraiblonde

Board Mommy
PREMO Member
Patron
I use this exact collar and I assure you that my dogs neck looks nothing like this. Clearly the owner shouldn't have a dog, you would have to pull with an incredible amount of force for the back of the neck to have lacerations.

Did anyone bother to read this?

I am usually suspicious of these outrageous rabble rousing memes, and like to do a quick google to make sure I'm not just being a reactionary nut when I freak out.

Veterinary Q&A: Prong collars are safe — fact or fiction?
http://seattletimes.com/html/tailso...rong_collars_are_safe_--_fact_or_fiction.html

As a dog owner, I will say that I use prong collars on my two large-breed dogs, a German shepherd and a pointer-mix. When the prong collars are on my dogs, they rarely pull on the lead; however, without the feel of the collar they are much more likely to be straining their necks against their soft collars.
 

ICit

Jam out with ur clam out
dont even get me started.....

This picture is very misleading.... THIS DOES NOT happen by using his type of TRAINING COLLAR. This happens by leaving the collar on for week and months as the dog is growing.

and this does not happen by swinging the dog around with this collar.


This type of collar is a training collar... to be used in a training method or used for corrections... THATS IT...

this is one of the SAFEST collars to ever use on your dog as long as you know how to use it.


I have used these collars for years and never had a problem. what i have an issue is the effing retards out there that dont understand how to CORRECTLY train their dogs and understand k9 behavior.

I laugh at the fools who are using the choke collars as those are the most damaging collars out there...
 

vraiblonde

Board Mommy
PREMO Member
Patron
this is one of the SAFEST collars to ever use on your dog as long as you know how to use it.

I have used these collars for years and never had a problem. what i have an issue is the effing retards out there that dont understand how to CORRECTLY train their dogs and understand k9 behavior.

:thewave:
 

MR47930

Member
Did anyone bother to read this?

I am usually suspicious of these outrageous rabble rousing memes, and like to do a quick google to make sure I'm not just being a reactionary nut when I freak out.

Veterinary Q&A: Prong collars are safe — fact or fiction?
http://seattletimes.com/html/tailso...rong_collars_are_safe_--_fact_or_fiction.html

No one reads anything anymore that goes against the point they are trying to make. Thank you for taking 5 seconds to research the facts. Used correctly as a training collar this is the best tool out there.
 

sm8

Active Member
If it were to have come from the collar the dog would of had to been backing away, If a dog is pulling you the wounds would be on the underside of the neck. I have seen some pretty bad lacerations on a dogs neck from a fabric collar also. It was a little dog I found in the road and picked up to take to the vet to see if it was chipped. The vet tech told me they were not supposed to provide care for a stray but she cut the collar out anyway for fear it would get worse before someone tended to it.
 

ICit

Jam out with ur clam out
If it were to have come from the collar the dog would of had to been backing away, If a dog is pulling you the wounds would be on the underside of the neck. I have seen some pretty bad lacerations on a dogs neck from a fabric collar also. It was a little dog I found in the road and picked up to take to the vet to see if it was chipped. The vet tech told me they were not supposed to provide care for a stray but she cut the collar out anyway for fear it would get worse before someone tended to it.

that photo is NOT from the dog getting a correction from the collar.... if it was there would be bruising and soft tissue trauma.... this IS from the collar being left on and the dog growing and becoming embedded in the neck....

if you all knew how this collar worked you would know (use your detective skills) that when you give a correction to a dog with this collar it will be given to the UNDERSIDE of the neck as the link hooked to the collar would be on top of the neck... seeing that the wounds are mainly on the TOP SIDE OF THE DOGS NECK indicates that the collar has been left on and is too small for the dog. these collars should never be that tight as it is only used for a quick and fast motion in correcting the dog... the movement should never be a steady pull... they are short small leash "snaps" that SHALL NEVER fully engage the collar all the way tight.
 

ZARA

Registered User
Now that every one has had a chance to see, read and form an opinion, I will weigh in.

Looks are all ways deceiving.
That collar is a tool. Just like a gun is a tool.
The collar alone cannot harm the dog unless a irresponsible human is present.
 
Top