Good thread. In between the personal bickering, there have been a few good points made. However - I think that everybody who is arguing against legalization based on the premise that drug use is bad/unhealthy is missing the point. Sam came closest to the real issue.
SamSpade said:
And I take it you didn't smoke a lot of dope in college. I did. It was hard to quit, because a) it was way too easy to do when you had nothing else to do and b) life without it was crap. Once I moved away from where it was easy to get, I could put it behind me.
You want to end recreational drug use? Can't do it by physically removing access to the drugs. Simply can't be done; we tried prohibiting alcohol and failed, and we've tried taking away pot and all sorts of other drugs and continue to fail. You have to look at what
causes drug use in the first place. Drugs are simply a temporary escape from your problems. Boredom, poverty, mental illness, unemployment, the list goes on. If we can help people address the real problems in life, drug use would decrease. If you already have an active, fulfilling life, why smoke up?
I experimented some in college, too, and drank heavily. Continued to drink heavily for some time after college until I got some self-confidence and got my s*** together. Add in a wonderful wife and a decent career, and now I don't touch drugs of any sort beyond the occasional beer. There are too many other things in life to be enjoyed.
So in the end, legalize it, don't legalize it; tax it, don't tax it. Doesn't matter a bit. For the record, I think we should legalize it simply because I hate to see so many resources thrown down the crapper fighting a futile battle in which so many people get hurt.
SamSpade said:
I like to listen to Jerry Doyle on the drive home (he used to star in my all-time favorite sci-fi series). One of his short sound bites is encouraging the legalization of marijuana, and commenting about people suffering and dying. Let's be honest - marijuana is not a CURE for anything. It makes people feel better while they suffer. So do a lot of drugs. It's not a case for legalization.
Now as for this point, I couldn't agree more. There are plenty of arguments for legalizing pot, but it makes me cringe to hear people try to tout pot as medicine.
So there's my 2 cents. I hope my avatar doesn't undermine my credibility too much for this topic.