There is a part of me, that has to agree with you, although I wish it weren't so. After all these years, I have, or had, found myself, growing more and more, to be a fan of Tiger. He's a winner, no doubt about it.
Positives? Well, he seemed to me to be a thoughtful kind of guy. When he won an event, he celebrated, as anyone would, depending on the worth, or value of the importance of the event he just conquered, but I didn't see, or notice anything overboard, about his display of emotions.
He won, dammit! Is that wrong?
Win after win - he was the guy who seemed to be the most capable of pulling out the victory. And he did!
But, something wasn't quite there. Something was escaping him, or so it would seem. He was a winner at the links, but not apparently, at his home.
I hope he can get it all together, eventually, because we will miss him.