I'm a pretty traditional person so if it's your first marriage, my *opinion* would be full-blown wedding vs. courthouse. It doesn't have to be lavish, but trust me, the memories from picking out the dress to the ceremony and reception are priceless. We had a big wedding and were fortunate to have friends and family members who were professional printers, florists, hair stylists, etc. so we (and by "we" I mean my parents) were able to cut some costs. You can still have a nice wedding and reception without going overboard. I just went to a friend's wedding which was pretty fancy and I'm sure the bride and most of the guests, myself included, will remember it for a long, long time. It still comes down to personal preference though. Good luck!