There is a problem with ....
Contemporary interpretation of catastrophes...
WE ARE NOT LOOKING AT THINGS FROM AN ETERNAL PERSPECTIVE!
Secularists look at the cycles of history and believe the rises & falls all are random and all we can do is avoid mistakes in the past by learning about them.
Providential Believers see a beginning and an end. There have been events that have paralyzed a generation that greatly profitted the next generation. It may have sparked reform, or reawakened generosity, or restored faith.
Christ was even asked about a bunch of guys who died when a wall collapsed on them (sorry...no reference: 2nd Amend help me out here) and he did NOT blame it on some group sin they committed.
God's Providence involves recognition of His Sovereignty, and His immutable laws. We bear the consequences when facing things like lung cancer from smoking or Aids from being queer but we also bear the weight of nature "groaning" from its fallen state.
I do not need to search for the "WHY?"...only search for the "When?"