What you were saying made it sound like you understood exactly where they were coming from and knew the reasoning behind every single statement made. That part I disagreed with because sometimes their reasoning is emotional and doesn't have "logic" behind it, making it impossible to really understand the "reasoning" since there's no true "reason." That doesn't invalidate their opinion, it just makes it hard to figure out what to do about it
:
Their reasoning is emotional and illogical FROM our view. I'm not talking about some sort of 'well, elephants SHOULD be able to fly' type thing. I'm talking about totally different approaches they sometimes, often, have that make no sense to us BECAUSE of how we are viewing it that, however, are perfectly good ideas or approaches if you step back and just listen.
I can't count how many times I approached something from 'guy way' and got totally annoyed that she couldn't see THE OBVIOUS when, later on, I would step back and say, "Oh, yeah, uh, well, that would have worked, too...". I, we, get caught up in our approach and, sometimes, we're the ones totally missing the point but, have a harder time seeing it because we tend to be linear. What they are saying makes NO sense and has NO reasoning behind it...from how we were approaching it.
PERFECT example; my ex is moving out today and is out at settlement. Bought a house. So, she wants to use my trailer and that's fine. This AM we discussed her using my truck and my linear view is that it is the more logical vehicle to use.
So, just now, she texts me "I'd be more comfortable using my truck than yours because of this and this..."
My response was "That doesn't have to be decided right now" and my thought is "Well, she feels bad about using my truck and I don't want her to. She'll see reason when she gets back and just use my truck."
Her response? "I just didn't want you going through the trouble of hooking your truck up to it yet."
Now, as a guy, it's 'why didn't you just say that in the first place?'. Right? Well, as a woman, they don't, typically, do direct approach. They're trying to be nice, to offer other reasons "I'm used to my truck" or what have you that might sound nicer or whatever.
I can extrapolate this out to any number of incidents with all the women in my life, sisters, mom, girlfriends, daughters, wives, etc. It simply boils down to guy way/girl way and it can be approach, perception of the issue, whatever.
One of the saddest days of my life was when my step son went off to boot camp. I had to sit there and watch someone I completely understood, with zero effort, and could communicate with with a grunt or nod, and watch understanding and familiarity go away.