AI - Taylor or Katherine

[canuk woman]

It's their show. They can do whatever they want to maximize the ratings and profits. You being from a socialist country like Canada probably don't understand that companies need to make a profit for their owners in order to stay in business.

Yeah but if it were up to me I would make them to a rematch just like ABC was forced to do a Dancing with the Stars rematch which I know already is very different.

 

[Dondi]

To date, the results of this poll is overwhelmingly in favor of Taylor 4 to 1:

Taylor - 28
Katherine - 7

This ought to be an interesting finale. I wonder how the national vote will go.

 

[Geek]

Love me some Taylor!!!!

 

[Claff]

I voted for Taylor, his talent and quirkiness wins out over her b0ouncing b00bies.

Barely.

/Chris shoulda won
//Idol addiction is our dirty little secret
///B0uncing b00bies usually trumps pretty much anything else except here

 

[dems4me]

Go Katherine!! I got a free dinner riding on this

 

[Katt]

Go Katherine!! I got a free dinner riding on this

I'm with you, Dems..... Katherine all the way! Taylor is okay, but a little of him goes a long way. I can't see myself buying a CD of his. His herky-Jerky movements get on my nerves some.

 

[dems4me]

I'm with you, Dems..... Katherine all the way! Taylor is okay, but a little of him goes a long way. I can't see myself buying a CD of his. His herky-Jerky movements get on my nerves some.

You just like her because you both have the same nicname I just can't see Taylor putting out anything new... just rehashing kareoke kind of songs... nothing orignial -- I don't think he's made any song yet on the entire season "his own" - just rehash after rehash... Katherine too isn't all that either - especially because you have to wonder what kind of songs she'll be singing after she's tried several times to sing songs "out of her leaque" and it was painfully obvious she "not there yet"... but for a free dinner, my vote is with Katherine Maybe both of them can cut cds singing duets or something I dont' think either is really good, but again, I think Katt does show more promise (barely)

 

[BuddyLee]

You just like her because you both have the same nicname I just can't see Taylor putting out anything new... just rehashing kareoke kind of songs... nothing orignial -- I don't think he's made any song yet on the entire season "his own" - just rehash after rehash... Katherine too isn't all that either - especially because you have to wonder what kind of songs she'll be singing after she's tried several times to sing songs "out of her leaque" and it was painfully obvious she "not there yet"... but for a free dinner, my vote is with Katherine Maybe both of them can cut cds singing duets or something I dont' think either is really good, but again, I think Katt does show more promise (barely)

Plus he can't even kick the microphone stand over.

 

[Ken King]

Plus he can't even kick the microphone stand over.

You're just jealous because you look like a microphone stand.

 

[Katt]

You're just jealous because you look like a microphone stand.

 

[sunflower]

Its on... Go Taylor

 

[K_Jo]

Its on... Go Taylor

Silver Nuts wins the first song!

 

[sunflower]

Taylor

 

[Claff]

Man these original songs they're having them sing as their first singles are always pure nauseating unadulterated schlock. And she's no Kelly Clarkson.

 

[K_Jo]

Man, that was McPhlat as hell.

 

[OldHillcrestGuy]

Go Katt

 

[Geek]

Silver Nuts will win

 

[Geek]

Man these original songs they're having them sing as their first singles are always pure nauseating unadulterated schlock. And she's no Kelly Clarkson.

I have heard farts that would play better on the radio.

 

[bresamil]

Although McPhee nailed "Over the Rainbow", Taylor's got it.

 

[BadGirl]

I am so proud to say that I have NEVER watched American Idol, nor will I ever watch it in the future.