I hadn't realized how many people were switching back to the old way. I was a former Mach3 user until I just started looking at how much I spent on cartridges a year. I picked up a Muhle razor and a nice badger hair brush for fairly cheap online. I also found a place that did a sampler pack of different brand blades and tried them all. You really don't realize how much of a gimmick all those extra blades are until you try out shaving with a DE razor. I ended up settling on Astras and found a case of 100 for $18 4 years ago and I'm still not even halfway through them.
I initially searched locally also but found nothing but really low quality junk. I still have 4 of the 5 blades I bought at Walmart to try 5 years ago. I'm really not sure why I still have them, it was like shaving with sandpaper. The closest thing to local I found was the Art of Shaving in Annapolis and I agree it is way overpriced. I like Taylor of Old Bond Street for soaps which is half the price of Art of Shaving's soap, comes in more varieties and I think lathers better. Unfortunately, just like the blades, no one around here sells it.