That's what I said last night! I was a little surprised, because the other food was very good & tasted authentic. (enough)
I ordinarily don't go out to a restaurant for Italian anyway, because I'd rather make it myself. But it was for his birthday and his choice. But I'd order the eggplant parmigiana for takeout, even!
I'm the same way. We don't have many restaurants to choose from in Dunkirk so when we go there I usually just stare at the menu. I'll have to try the eggplant next time.