Better Late Than Never
This is my first post on your friendly message board so I thought I would jump in on the tail end of and interesting question. I did not read the previous replies so as not to be biased.
First off, many people who post on dating service boards do so more out of curiosity and many do no have the nerve to follow through beyond e-mail exchanges. There is something to be said about this insecure sort of person but that is a different subject. Regardless, not all apparant rejections are based on the likes or dislikes of a given photo.
In my mind if someone is looking to meet another person via an on-line dating service than it is in their best interest to be as honest as possible as eventually you run the risk of having to meet your mystery date and the out come may be upleasant if you have purposfully decieved someone. Truth be know, there is someone out there waiting for all of us and it is a combination of patience, persistence and a bunch of luck if we stumble onto the right match.
I speak the obvious when I state that there is a big difference between an intimate relationship versus a strong friendship with the opposite sex. My friendships are not based on a ladies weight, age, looks, financial resources, social standing, education or any other discriminators that take away from her values as a person but rather how she treats me as a friend. She could weigh 300 pounds and if we clicked as friends it would be and honest and true friendship.
On the other hand, in order to want to go beyond friendships to a more intimate realationship, I as a person (just my opinion) have to be attracted to a lady and that is defined by much more than weight alone. I could very easily be attracted to a lady that was extreamly short, very tall, who has toes that look like they grew from a potato, hair that flew everywhere (but was clean), wore clothing that was loud and miss matched, worked in a sardine packing factory, or even grew up in Southern MD (smile). On the other hand I would normally not seek out an intimate relationship with a really heavy lady. However, a friendship with a heavy person could eventually develop into an intimate realationship.
last but certainly not least is how do you define the description of "rather large". It is one thing to weigh 175 pounds when your body frame and age dictates 130 but if your over 200 pounds and climbing steady than we move from the "chubby" and "Plump" category to something of greater significance.
If someone passes instant juedgement on someone just because they are a bit over weight than shame on them and your friend should thank him for the favor. On the other hand if she is only in her mid 30's and a bit over weight than for her own good will and benefit and not for someone on EHarmony, maybe she needs to make an attempt to fit into a size or two smaller. As I have aged I have NOT put on considerable weight but it certainly has shifted and repositioned itself a bit. Last I looked I have not made the cover of any ladies magazines but I am comfortable with who I am and what I am as a person. I would encourage your friend to bring forth the positive elements she has to offer which I assume are many and to establish a small goal to improve on the least significant aspect of her life that seems to have unfortunately the greatest impact to her self esteem and happiness.
Thanks for the opportunity and this was different as I normally post on a Potomac River Message Board where the subject matter is much different. Any ladies (Large or small) want to go fishing?
Jim
PS: Good luck to your friend.