I LOVE...
...hypothetical questions. It doesn't matter what I say because there is no way I can get in trouble for merely having an opinion!
MY thoughts on the test case at issue:
ENTIRELY his fault??? My daddy always said "...it takes two to tango...and if you find a box of chocolates, eat them %uckers before anybody else knows you got 'em..."
It seems to me that the dynamics of intimate human relations oft manifest themselves in mysterious, intriguing ways.
For instance, what if our hero had made no peace offering, say left a flaming paper bag full of #### instead? What would THAT say? Fairly thoughtful yes, but not particularly endearing.
Perhaps this fine fellow is, err, could be, merely a man of action and not words? A "Superman' if you will.
What if the poor chap is mute and has no other means of communicating save gestures and tokens of affection?
I would postulate that whatever the particulars of this given hypothesis, that the memory of this little set to will tend towards the warm and fuzzy rather than thoughts of a few words, no matter how well chosen.
Besides, if a man extracts himself from a minefield the same way all the time, oh, how boring. Hypothetically speaking of course.
It seems most of the fine people in this thread are very intelligent, bright, perceptive and just plain good people with common sense save for perhaps this "Mean Queen" person who is a known golf club kisser and non-gender specific mechanical animal rider and I think we can all agree that those are disqualifying habits in most of the original 13 colonies and some 66% of the one third of the earth not actually under water.
Implausible, but a great scenario anyway! No one could be lucky enough to have guy like that.