So folks...
...as your all dressed up replete with pitchforks and torches, wanna hear the rest of the story, my side, before the lynching?
I didn't think so.
When #2 asked about the party and was told no, she also asked if she could then have some friends over. I said yes. One of the parents later claims they did not hear this. No one had moved. We were all in the same proximity. Same time.
Now, what is a typical number for #2 to have over? 2-4. That's normal. Are they loud? Do the Redskins stink this year? Are they in OUR home, otherwise behaving and NOT off somewhere else, out of sight, out of mind? Do the Redskins really stink this year?
Is it common for one parent to say OK to sleepovers on their own? No. Without exception, there is at least an understanding that the other knows and is cool with it. So, if one parent thought the other heard what the one parent heard, IE, 'can I have some friends over', and a 'I don't see why not', well, might we have the seeds of a misunderstanding rather than a federal case?
Now, #3 says 'can I have over some friends to?' I said no at first because it is common to try and limit one or the other for sleepovers. It is also common to say OK, especially when it is #3 because her friends are...calmer. So, #3 says, "Oh, dad, it's just Emmy and Kirky, and we'll be in my room all night!' So, being this horrible monster that likes to say 'yes' to the kids, guilty as charged, especially when it is something pretty normal that I would have guessed other parent was OK with, especially because I already thought they were.
So, #3 and her quiet pals are in her room all night, hardly a peep. #2 and her four roll in, laughing and giggling and make some noodles, grab some sodas and off to the basement to watch movies. Typical. Maybe quieter than normal.
No chips and cases of sodas. No 12 pizzas. No roaming the house laughing and screaming. No blaring music. No 50 kids and 1/2 dozen parents and extra calls for more everything. No paper plates and cups and napkins all over. Like last years cast party. Just the kids watching movies.
Some party, some party.
Now when other parent came home, she asked 'So, what's the deal?' I said #2 is having 4 and #3 is having 2. So, she's bent.
"So, they got their party after all?"
"It's 6 kids, not 50."
"You should have let me know first."
"You're right. I'm sorry."
We go round and round some more. What's the big deal, you shoulda let me know, it's too many kids, it's nothing unusual, ya da, ya da, round and round.
I DID think she'd heard the OK for friends over. 6 is NOT unusual and is a party only to Mormons and the people who live next door to the Simpson's. I DID acknowledge that I should have let her know, asked her, even though I already though it was OK and I did say I was SORRY.
All in all, to me, points on both sides, a dab of misunderstanding/miss communication and, viola, the anatomy of a rather typical tough parent/sap parent tiff.