OrneryPest said:
There's gonna be a neighborhood meeting about it tonight. Maybe I'll go, and see if I can comprehend their justification for it.
Well, folks, I went to the meeting. The overall concept is vastly different from what I had envisioned.
It's not just a roundabout in the usual sense, that would do nothing but give people another excuse to simply drive down onto the island so they could turn around and come back.
It's primarily an esthetic redesign of the intersection that, among other things, would permit a more pedestrian-friendly sidewalk arrangement, and also make it easier to get in and out with the 60-foot 18-wheelers that are sometimes needed for deliveries in the area.
No existing streets will be blocked off, and there is no intention of discouraging anybody from driving, walking, or bicycling around the block just like we've always been doing.
The only tree that would be ripped out is one of those weedy-soft maples that we've got millions of, and they break big branches off in every little storm anyhow. It's more of a gigantic weed than a real tree.
The community in general appears to be mostly in favor of the project, and I've decided I'm in favor of it, too.