Tonio
Asperger's Poster Child
I would have a problem with that, too. I tend to be skeptical of those kind of reports, because they leave out facts that shed a different light on the events. Any school system that would take that kind of action is just begging to be sued.2ndAmendment said:If the news reports are to be believed, the New York City schools allowed the Muslim crescent, Jewish menorah, and the Kwanzaa candles, but prohibited even pictures of a Nativity scene. That is a problem.
In my view, government entities should never endorse one religion over another. I see "separation of church and state" as meaning that the country should have no official religion or even an unofficial religion--hence my opposition to "Under God" in the Pledge. Religious observances in public places such as town squares are an entirely different matter. (BTW, I don't view classrooms as public places.) In a public place, any religious group, including athiest groups, should be able to set up their own holiday displays. So why do some local goverments try to prohibit all religious displays in town squares? I think it's because they're taking the lazy way out--they're not actively hostile to religion.
Although I think the Pledge issue is one of democratic principle, you make a good point. Although I believe in God, I would never demand that everyone else believe in God, or try to stop others from believing in something else. My guess is that Newdow and O'Hair are in the minority among athiests--they just have an unhealthy craving for attention. They no more represent the majority of athiests any more than PETA represents the majority of vegetarians.What I object to is minorities of all kinds, religion, political, etc., trying to force others to stop observing whatever they observe because it offends them. This probably says it best regarding religion vs atheism.