Is that even possible to answer? If it is Buchanan, I'd have never fell in love with the electric guitar and I consider Danny Gatton well beyond Roy in that style of Tele-pickin' clean playing.
Tommy Emmanuel (thanks Psy) is stunning, just a breath taking, natural player.
There are any number of amazingly proficient players who are boring as all hell.
Malmsteen. Batio.
There are others who are so silky smooth they truly make it look effortless and their taste is impeccable.
Chet Atkins
Al DiMeola
Lots of people, including great guitar players, think it's Clapton who I've never thought much of.
Should it be by genre? Era? Based solely on what great guitar players think? That would make the most sense.
Where to even start?
It's all a matter of taste. I think we make it too complicated when it really just boils down to - what do you like?
I’ve made it no secret that Pat Metheny is my long-time mentor.
1) I agree about the best guitar player
2) Mentor ,really , he has always been a favorite of mine
You're a fan of Pat Metheny? This changes everything!
I play the guitar. I was turned on to Pat back in '78 and have followed him ever since. Before that I was into that speed guitar crap of Al DiMeola, John McLaughlin, etc... Metheny really slowed me down and caused me to start listening to the music rather than finding the next fast riff. Even today I am still obsessed with his playing.
Was born in 56 ,lived in the NY metro area and there was a radio station WNEW with the greatest DJ's ever ,and they played his group all the time .
THE PAT METHENY GROUP - THE WAY UP (Opening) - YouTube
And on the subject of guitar players... Jim Hall, one of the standard greats, died today at 83.
Heard a nice tribute on NPR today.