I hope they turn this docudrama script on its head and either something happens to the "actors" when they're filming the documentary or something happens to the people as they're narrating it.
I've enjoyed it so much though. It's like Murder House, with a little bit of The Shining and The Blair Witch Project thrown in.
Lee bringing her daughter to a house where weird scary crap is going on was just stupid. Lee herself is stupid and a waste of Angela Bassett.
Shelby is that PTA mom you want to slap, with her gluten allergies and yoga "business" and general touchy feely baby girl idiocy.
Cuba Gooding Jr is way too hot and cool to be playing that dweeb.
The stereotypes are way WAY over the top. The Carolina neighbors, for example. The cops. Etc.
What I do like is that the "real" people are plain looking and somewhat stupid, while the actors playing them are good looking and more attractive in general. For example, notice Lily Rabe wears no makeup and looks mousy and boring, but Sarah Paulson is made up, dressed, and beautiful. That lends a touch of realism that I like.