Radiant1
Soul Probe
Fair 'nuff. So let me ask you... If Bob were on life support and a quack doctor wanted to pull the plug on him you'd allow him to choose life or death over your husband?
Planned Parenthood
- Thread starter libby
- Start date
Fair 'nuff. So let me ask you... If Bob were on life support and a quack doctor wanted to pull the plug on him you'd allow him to choose life or death over your husband?
BadGirl
I am so very blessed
I'm not about to start with you in your personal opinion on my beliefs or family concerns. It's none of your business.
Radiant1
Soul Probe
That's fine. I'll just mark this up to the illogic of those who are pro-choice. :shrug:
BadGirl
I am so very blessed
It's really wonderful how you can determine just who is logical and who is illogical by my 22 word post.
sockgirl77
Well-Known Member
Dear Leg Pee'r,
What would you do if you were raped and got knocked up? Keep the baby and have the reminder every day that you were brutally raped?
Pee'd On,
Socki
P.S. I am Pro Choice.
AndyMarquisLIVE
New Member
Wow, 35 pages of 
puggymom
Active Member
Wow, 35 pages of
tommyjones
New Member
see thats just a stupid argument, a doctor wouldn't get to decide, it would be left up to the persons closet relative, or BFF as south park said. the only time this is an issue is when there is a disagreement between BFF and parents or other close family. In reality, if you get into a car accident and are on life support, your mom, or your BFF, if your mom isn't around would make the call.
If your mom decided that you keep living, you do. if she decides you have had enough, they pull the plug. Sounds familiar, dont it
This_person
Well-Known Member
I don't know anyone advocating forcing childbirth on anyone. I do not now nor have I ever suggested that people should go out and have sex to fill this void for other people.
But, if one should choose to go out and have sex, the consequences of that are pretty clear to anyone who does it willingly. Therefore, if they're looking for choices, they have many
- Don't have sex if you're not going to be willing to go full term with a pregnancy from it
- Be willing to raise the child from your sexual experience
- Know that there is a demand for your baby from good parents wishing to adopt
- Know whether you would have the support of family and friends to aid you in raising a child yourself
This_person
Well-Known Member
We're talking abortion choice here, I'm looking for babies - under a few months old, the ones that are comparable to the baby being killed as an option instead of having it and giving it up for adoption.
AndyMarquisLIVE
New Member
This_person
Well-Known Member
I applaud you for breaking it down to the actual argument of abortion, but I'm curious why you have this stance. I asked Go-G earlier at what stage he thinks this life becomes a life, and he said second trimester (though the question as to "why then" went unanswered). At what stage do you think this life becomes a life, and not something comparable to a tumor?
tommyjones
New Member
so we got the virgin, and the man who was scorned in agreement about what the rest of us should do
Andy, when you grow up you will realize that people have sex more often than not, with the intention of NOT making a baby. If those people get pregnant and decide to have an abortion it is NONE of your business, it doens't affect your life in any way.....
puggymom
Active Member
I know this is not to me but do you want my personal opinion from my experience being pregnant or what I believe the legal defination should be?
This_person
Well-Known Member
None, I've been too busy raising the family I chose to have, taking care of my own responsibilities.
You mean, like every natural death is investigated as a murder? Or, are you just trying to stir the pot with dishonest questions?
Who have miscarriages, or abortions once they're illegal?[/quote]also, no more in vitro fertilization. Guess they can just adopt hehe[/QUOTE]We've discussed the IVF quite a bit before. As I say, those fertilized eggs that do not become babies are more like miscarriages than abortions, or like when a doctor tries to save (make) a life and fails. That's not murder, that's unfortuante.
sockgirl77
Well-Known Member
so we got the virgin, and the man who was scorned in agreement about what the rest of us should do
Andy, when you grow up you will realize that people have sex more often than not, with the intention of NOT making a baby. If those people get pregnant and decide to have an abortion it is NONE of your business, it doens't affect your life in any way.....
I 100% agree with you.
This_person
Well-Known Member
Of course!
That's the whole point of the discussion - respectful (from most of us) exchange of ideas.
tommyjones
New Member
I 100% agree with you.
and we are both parents and understand completely what is at stake......
what some woman decides to do with her pregnancy is her choice, the way it should be, control freaks and virgins need not be consulted.
puggymom
Active Member
also, no more in vitro fertilization. Guess they can just adopt hehe[/QUOTE]We've discussed the IVF quite a bit before. As I say, those fertilized eggs that do not become babies are more like miscarriages than abortions, or like when a doctor tries to save (make) a life and fails. That's not murder, that's unfortuante.[/QUOTE]
If abortion is defined as murder do you honestly believe that some people wanting out will not try to induce a miscarriage? And if a fetus is given the same legal status as an already born human wouldn't they have a right to an investigation into their 'murder' intentional or not?