What I'm saying is that one large metropolitan area shouldn't dictate the whole state, because their needs and concerns aren't the same.
In Maryland, for example, the dictates of Baltimore and the DC metro set the agenda for places like SM and Calvert Counties and Western MD that have nothing to do with those urban areas.
View attachment 162404
All those people in the red areas aren't represented in their state government. Then they get gerrymandered even further and now it's like they don't even exist. That happened in 6D when they gerrymandered it to dig into Montgomery County and turn it blue by disenfranchising all those people in Garrett, Allegany, Frederick, and Washington Counties. In fact, in 2014 John Delaney barely beat Dan Bongino for the House and he only won one single county - Montgomery. Bongino won the rest. That's a true story, you can look it up.
That gerrymandering scheme went to the Supremes, who said, "Meh, that's a state issue." And because the Democrats had a lock on the state, the disenfranchisement stood. So since then folks in rural Garrett County have been ruled by guys from DC, and in effect have no representation in either their state or federal government. That hardly seems American to me.