American Idol/Queen

Toxick

Splat
I was moderately disappointed.

I was hoping that there would be no "Bohemian Rhaposody", and no "We Will Rock You". I have to give Kudos to Taylor for scrapping "We Are the Champions". Those songs are way played out, and I was hoping for something a little different.

Best performance was easily, Elliot. The first couple of seconds when he started singing, it kind of freaked me out, because Mercury sang that song with an lilty high-pitch voice, and Elliot sang in his normal voice - but after you get past that, he scored a hit with that one.

I loved Paris last night. I thought she nailed that one too.

Chris did good, but what the hell was he thinking by picking that song? Simon was right, the song choice was self-indulgent and it was a major disappointment for me.

I thought Ace, Bucky and Catherine did OK - but not anything special. I also thnk they're going to be the bottom 3 tonight, with probably Ace taking a bow.


And for the first time, I was entertained by Pickler. Like I said I didn't want to hear that song, but I really think she did great with it. She didn't make it all country-fried, thank God. It was something new for her, and I think she rocked it.



And did she really tell Simon, "I don't have an accent?"

I know I must have heard that wrong.
 

slotted

New Member
Is anyone actually listening when Chris sings? Awful every week.

The mofo from Richmond with the jacked up grill is actually the best singer out of the bunch.
 

Abby

Abby
slotted said:
The mofo from Richmond with the jacked up grill is actually the best singer out of the bunch.

Couldn't agree more... I always have to close my eyes when he sings or I'll hate it no matter how well he performs. Video killed the radio star!

Of course, he'll get that crap fixed when he signs a recording contract.

LOVE Chris, but he belongs on "Rock Star", not this mainstream show. Can't wait for that show to come back... (http://rockstar.msn.com/ they've chosen a new band)
 

BuddyLee

Football addict
Abby said:
LOVE Chris, but he belongs on "Rock Star", not this mainstream show.
:confused: I was under the impression that a lot of American's idolize rock stars.

He adds a little flavor to the prep-filled show.
 

Tina2001aniT

New Member
OK, so this is bad....

I call to check on the kiddo (she is 7, and stayed with a friend last night, it's spring break for them) and first words out of her mouth.....
"hey mom, who do you think did good on American Idol last night, cause I didn't get to watch it" :banghead: oops :blushing:
 

gumby

I AM GUMBY DAMMIT
slotted said:
Is anyone actually listening when Chris sings? Awful every week.

The mofo from Richmond with the jacked up grill is actually the best singer out of the bunch.


Thank God. I thought I was the only one who doesn't like Chris. He reminds me too much of the band "Live". I can't stand Ed Kawalchek(sp?)
 

slotted

New Member
gumby said:
Thank God. I thought I was the only one who doesn't like Chris. He reminds me too much of the band "Live". I can't stand Ed Kawalchek(sp?)
He sounds like Creed every week. ES Tee EFFF UUU already Chris! :elaine:
 

Geek

New Member
Taylor was amazing. I was really surprised at Simon. I thought Catherine and Ace did great too. I did not vote, fell asleep.
 

slotted

New Member
Geek said:
Taylor was amazing. I was really surprised at Simon. I thought Catherine and Ace did great too. I did not vote, fell asleep.
Poor Bucky. He reminded me of Jason Mewes (Jay, from Jay and Silent Bob).
 

sugarmama

New Member
Thank GOD bucky is finally gone.
Taylor and catherine--they're going to be the final 2.
Paris or ace needs to go home next week.
 

Otter

Nothing to see here
Its gonna come down to Chris and the black girl. The girl is fantastic and Chris probably has the whole female population between 12 and 30 dialing his number every week.
 

Geek

New Member
slotted said:
Poor Bucky. He reminded me of Jason Mewes (Jay, from Jay and Silent Bob).


That's it! I could not place who he reminded me of. Thank you. Poor Bucky he is cute, but now I do not want to see anyone leave. Is it just me or is the talent really good this year?
 
M

missperky

Guest
I am soooooooooooooooo glad Bucky is gone, I never liked him.
 

Toxick

Splat
sugarmama said:
Thank GOD bucky is finally gone.
Taylor and catherine--they're going to be the final 2.
Paris or ace needs to go home next week.

Not a chance that Taylor is going to out-live Chris. I pegged Chris to go to the Final 2 during his audition, and nothing I've seen since has changed my mind.

And I doubt that Catherine is going to outlive Kellie - Unless she starts wearing low cut blouses and miniskirts and effectively appropriating the entire 15-35 male crowd.





I think the final two SHOULD be Chris and Elliot.

I think the final two WILL be Chris and Kellie.
 

Toxick

Splat
Geek said:
Is it just me or is the talent really good this year?

It's not just you.

It's been a banner year for AI. The past 2-3 weeks have been a touch shaky, but when they start the 'theme weeks' they usually are, until the last few episodes.


Anyone catch what next weeks' theme is?
 

GeezLouise

tired and content....
Toxick said:
It's not just you.

It's been a banner year for AI. The past 2-3 weeks have been a touch shaky, but when they start the 'theme weeks' they usually are, until the last few episodes.


Anyone catch what next weeks' theme is?


Rod Stewart :ohwell:

Should be interesting.....
 
Top