Ken King said:
Difference between 1st degree and 2nd degree is mostly that of intent (and of course the use of a weapon makes it a 1st degree offense). Given the drinking and prescription medication the charge should be the 2nd degree one. Now if the girl friend was not severely injured and she is willing she can meet with his lawyer and request a dismissal of charges.
Not sure what lawyers are good and aren't of those listed but I have used Tom Pelligotti for crap my son got into years ago. Any prior convictions, as that might be a show stopper for the court considering the dismissal as being proper.
Mr. King ,
I want to thank you very much for that input. I was able to speak with my mother and ny brothers girlfriend and was able to speak with a law office in St. Marys County this morning. Not a lawyer but someone who worked in the office.
We said exactly what you had asked and it seems that your advice was correct and most beneficial. I cannot thank you and everyone else for your help.
We also were able to request the Doctor write a statement as to his past history and the affects the mixing the two together may have caused. His doctor has treated him for a long time on a regular basis and is willing to state that he illustrated no previous signs of alcohol dependency or any apparent issues with anger that may have been apparent with a Doctor –Patient relationship. (those were the words from the Doctors office). So we are on the right track for now.
I am sorry for those that doubt the sincerity of this topic. While I do respect your opinions and appreciate your input, I really am looking for something that would be a little more proactive in dealing with this situation.
Granted, it is hard to get the whole story out on a message board but to be fair, it would be nice if you gave me the benefit of the doubt until proven otherwise. I have nothing to gain otherwise, but was only seeking help.