Care to think about that statement for a bit? .
No, because there are guys who are just heinous wretches, that aren't even worth consideration and your girlfriends should slap you silly for even talking to them, let alone dating them. And then there are perfectly good guys who aren't model gorgeous, aren't Bill Gates rich, sometimes get drunk and act silly, occasionally are thoughtless, but they're all around good men who deserve a shot.
We're talking about extremes here. I don't think you were unreasonable to wait for Day - he's a good guy. But I have a girlfriend who would rip him to shreds because he's not handsome enough, or rich enough, or whatever. She's married to a really handsome, rich guy who cheats on her now.